In the world of music analysis, not all data is created equal. A recent deep dive into chord progressions using Ultimate Guitar tabs has online commentators scratching their heads and calling foul.

The study claims to reveal the most common chords across genres, but musicians are quick to point out some head-scratching results. Power chords in metal? Supposedly only 5.8% - a statistic that has guitarists laughing out loud. Jazz musicians are equally skeptical, with one noting that seventh chords are far more prevalent than the analysis suggests.

The real issue lies in the data source. Ultimate Guitar, while popular, is notorious for user-submitted tabs that are often simplified, incomplete, or just plain wrong. It's like trying to understand a novel by reading cliff notes scribbled by teenagers. Some online commentators argue that the analysis misses crucial nuances - like how chords are actually played, not just written down.

Musicologists and tech enthusiasts alike are calling for a more sophisticated approach. They want relative chord progressions, not just absolute chords. Imagine analyzing language by counting individual words without understanding grammar - that's essentially what this study does to music.

Despite its flaws, the study sparks an interesting conversation about music theory, data analysis, and the complexity hidden in seemingly simple songs. It's a reminder that sometimes, the most interesting insights come from understanding what data doesn't tell us.